Albert Ellis, Ph.D. (1958-1960)
Christopher Tietze, M.D. (1960-1962)
Hans Lehfeldt, M.D. (1962-1964)
Henry Guze, Ph.D. (1964-1966)
Wardell Pomeroy, Ph.D. (1966-1968)
Richard D. Amelar, M.D. (1968-1970)
Jack Lippes, M.D. (1970-1972)
John Money, Ph.D. (1972-1974)
Richard Green, M.D. (1974-1977)
Leah C. Schaefer, Ed.D. (1978-1979)
William E. Hartman, Ph.D. (1979-1980)
Ira L. Reiss, Ph.D. (1980-1981)
Vern L. Bullough, Ph.D. (1981-1983)
Joseph LoPiccolo, Ph.D. (1983-1984)
Clive M. Davis, Ph.D. (1984-1985)
Elizabeth R. Allgeier, Ph.D. (1985-1986)
David P. McWhirter, M.D. (1986-1987)
Donald L. Mosher, Ph.D. (1987-1988)
Kenneth D. George, Ed.D. (1988-1989)
Eli Coleman, Ph.D. (1989-1990)
Marilyn Story, Ph.D. (1990-1991)
Donn Byrne, Ph.D. (1991-1992)
Pepper Schwartz, Ph.D. (1992-1993)
William Yarber, H.S.D. (1993-1994)
Naomi McCormick, Ph.D. (1994-1995)
Richard Keeling, M.D. (1995-1996)
Charlene Muehlenhard, Ph.D. (1996-1997)
Stephanie A. Sanders, Ph.D. (1997-1998)
Elaine Hatfield, Ph.D. (1998-1999)
Janet Shibley Hyde, Ph.D. (1999-2000)
Michael Wallis Ross, Ph.D. (2000-2001)
Milton Diamond, Ph.D. (2001-2002)
Beverly Whipple, Ph.D. (2002-2003)
Andrew Mattison, Ph.D. (2003-2004)
Walter Bockting, Ph.D. (2004-2005)
Patricia Koch, Ph.D. (2005-2007)
Suzanne Frayser, Ph.D. (2007-2008)
Konstance McCaffree, Ph.D. (2008-2009)
Herb Samuels, Ph.D.(2009-2010)
Konstance McCaffree, Ph.D. (2010-2011)
Bean Robinson, Ph.D. (2011-2012)
Jean Levitan, Ph.D. (2012-2013)
Michael Reece, Ph.D. (2013-2014)
Osmo Kontula, Ph.D. (2014-2015)
Terry Humphreys, Ph.D. (2015-2017)
Eric Walsh-Buhi, M.P.H., Ph.D. (2017-2019)
Zoë Peterson, Ph.D. (2019-2021)
Carlos Rodríguez-Díaz, PhD, MPHE, MCHES (2021-2023)